What safe means for a young child
Safety for a five year old covers several things at once. The answers should fit the child's age. Nobody should be selling to them. Their voice and words should be handled with care. And the app should fit into a healthy day instead of taking it over.
No app gets everything perfect, and no checklist replaces your own judgment. Use the questions below as a starting point. Try the app yourself before your child does, and trust what you see.
Check 1: Are the answers right for a young child?
Spend ten minutes using the app on your own. Ask the kind of questions your child asks every day. Then ask a few harder ones and watch how it responds.
- Ask a simple question, such as why the sky is blue. Is the answer short and in words your child knows?
- Ask something sad or grown-up, such as what happens when a pet dies. Does it answer gently and suggest talking with a parent?
- Ask it to say something unkind about someone. Does it politely refuse?
- Give a wrong answer to a math question on purpose. Does it correct you kindly and explain why?
- Ask about something it can't know, like your child's teacher's name. Does it admit it doesn't know?
Check 2: Ads, purchases and data
Look for ads inside the app and for buttons that lead to purchases. Anything that costs money should sit behind a parent gate, a simple step that a young child can't get past alone.
Then read the privacy policy, or at least the summary. You want to know what is collected, whether voice recordings are kept, and whether anything is sold or shared for advertising. Apps in the App Store's Kids category agree to stricter store rules on ads and tracking, which is a good sign to look for.
As one example, the Albert Teacher AI app for iPhone and iPad is in the App Store's Kids category and has no ads. Albert's privacy policy says personal information is not sold or shared for marketing, and that voice audio is sent to OpenAI to be processed during the session and is not stored by Albert. Hold every app, Albert included, to the same questions.
- Are there ads of any kind?
- Are purchases behind a parent gate?
- What data is collected, including voice?
- Is any data sold or shared for advertising?
- Can you ask for your child's data to be deleted?
- Is there a clear way to contact the company about privacy?
Check 3: Parental controls and what you can see
A good learning app lets you see what your child has been doing. Check whether you can look back at the topics they explored, and whether you can set limits on time or features.
Also check where the app can lead. A young child's app should be a closed space. It should not open the wider web, and it should not let your child chat with strangers or other users.
Check 4: Supervision and screen time
For children under seven, sit nearby for the first few sessions and keep the device in a shared room after that. You will hear what your child asks and how the app replies, which tells you more than any policy page.
Short sessions usually work better than long ones for young children. Set a timer before you start, and stop at a natural end point, such as the end of a lesson. A good app should send your child back to real life: counting the stairs, drawing, or reading a book with you.
Check 5: Talk with your child about AI
Children understand more than we expect when we use simple words. Tell your child that the AI is a computer program. It is good with words, it can make mistakes, and it is not a person or a friend in the way people are.
- Never tell an app your full name, address, school or any password.
- If an answer feels strange or scary, stop and come and tell a grown-up.
- It's fine to check an answer with a parent or teacher.
- Being polite is good, and so is saying "I don't think that's right."